BlahBlahCafe - Jean-Michel Jarre forum

here's a list I found on wikipedia...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Je ... ple_titles

Who here agrees with me the following titles should not be on this list:




"Intro Saturée" (Water for Life concert, Merzouga, Morocco, December 16 2006 ) <> "Melancholic Rodeo" (Téo & Téa)

One similar sounding sound doesn't make it a new version of an "old" song IMO



"Je Me Souviens" (Metamorphoses) <> "Aero" * (AERO)

Really???



"Free Floating Anxiety" (Deserted Palace) <> "Une Morte dans la Neige" (Les Granges Brûlées)

Very different tracks IMO, although same instruments are used it's still not the same track



"Oxygene 2", first part (Oxygene) <> "Suite for Flute" (Water for Life concert, Merzouga, Morocco, December 16 2006 )

Suite for flute is the intro for oxygene 2... it's not a complete track so Intro's do count these days?


Track from Oxygene <> "Oxygene in the Ghetto" (single)

At best it's a remix or a rap version with an old sample... not exactly the same track IMO

I do as those tracks are pretty different, just a few similarities like an identical preset used for instance.

I deleted them and put a link to this page in the history.

Please keep me posted when something changes on that page so we can keep it correct...

I hate it when PPL make up stuff on wiki....


Now what about Give me a sign and <> "voyage to the acroplolis with Jean-Paul II"

Essentialy acro is a slow version of GMAS, but can it still qualify as the same track?

Input wanted!

Well It's the same melody so why not let it be? Otherwise you'll have to do the same with the rest of the listed tracks. 'La Belle Et La Bete' and 'La Morte Du Cygne' aren't the same as RV2 and RV3, but they are still based on the same melody.